WRR Blog
Fantasy Football
2008 NFL Draft
2007 Draft Archive
Hot Reads
Buy or Sell?
Prospect Interviews
About Us
Links
Home


 


Buy or Sell - Lorenzo Booker or Darius Walker - Better NFL RB Prospect

February 22, 2007
 

BUY-BOOKER
By Rob Tribbett
War Room Report Editor


Lorenzo Booker or
Darius Walker -
Who is the
better NFL prospect?



War Room Report Staff and Contributors

Justin Davis Booker
Justin Darghai Booker
Chris Otwell Booker
Brett Fisher Booker

BUY-WALKER
By Matt MacCoy
War Room Report Scout

Lorenzo Booker was the top running back prospect in the country when he entered Florida State in the fall of 2002 after becoming the all-time leading rusher in California prep football history. While his career at Florida State did not meet those expectations, Booker possesses all of the qualities needed for a successful career in the NFL.

The versatility Booker offers is difficult to find, as he can rush the ball, catch passes, and return kicks. He has homerun potential whenever he touches the ball, due to his terrific acceleration and elusiveness. When Booker gets to the outside, opposing defenders will have a difficult time bringing him down.

Booker has the route running skills and hands to immediately contribute as a third down back in the NFL. Booker can also use his quickness and moves on returning kicks, where he should provide instant value.

The NFL is evolving, with offensive minded coaches willing to use whatever weapons they have to attack the defense. A player like Booker is a valuable weapon to have, and in the right system, he will be able to pressure the defense with his blend of speed, elusiveness, and pass catching ability.

Darius Walker is not a bad player, but he has no special qualities. Where Booker possesses outstanding speed and can make players miss, plus good hands, Walker is just a workman like back that will never contribute at a high level. Walker does not have top end speed and can not make people miss, yet he lacks the strength to run over defenders.

Much is made about Walker’s success at Notre Dame, but other backs that have put up even better numbers in college and failed in the pros, because like Walker, they did not have any outstanding skills.

While Walker compares to players like Ciatrack Fason or Jonathan Wells, Booker’s playmaking ability is like a Brian Westbrook or Maurice Jones-Drew – if you get him the ball, good things will happen.

The NFL is about players showcasing elite talents. Booker has elite talent in several areas, while Walker is lacking elite talent in any. If Booker goes to a team that can utilize his talents effectively, he will have a long and productive career in the NFL.

 

In recent draft history, many running backs have been selected in the second round or later in the NFL Draft, and have some success. Many times it is the running back prospects that are unheralded that have success, whether it is immediate or eventual. I believe the next post-first round RB prospect to have success in the National Football League will be Darius Walker, out of the University of Notre Dame. 

Walker had the significant advantage of playing in an offense that was NFL oriented and not only stressed the ability to run the football, but also stressed pass blocking and catching the football out of the backfield, evidenced by the 100 receptions Darius Walker accumulated in the past two seasons combined. The Notre Dame pro style offense will allow for a smooth transition for Walker into the NFL, so I believe Walker will have success in the NFL, sooner rather than later. 

Darius Walker is 5’10 and 210 pounds, so he has the size to take the pounding that is a requirement to be a RB in the National Football League. He has the ability to run inside and to the outside. A well-rounded RB prospect that will most assuredly impress the scouts in Indianapolis during the Scouting Combine as it is my contention that he will run a 40 time even faster than the time that is being speculated and elevate his status even higher. 

My opposition in this case is taking another RB prospect Lorenzo Booker to be the better RB.  Booker is talented, but his career at Florida State was the definition of inconsistent. Darius Walker actually gained more rushing yards this past year in his junior campaign then Lorenzo Booker rushed for in his junior season AND senior season COMBINED! Walker also outweighs Booker by a solid 15 pounds without losing any explosiveness. This fact among many others makes Walker a more solid prospect to carry the load at the next level.

To conclude the argument, I must first point out that I like Lorenzo Booker as a RB prospect, just not as much as Darius Walker. Walker has all the tools and athletic ability to succeed in the National Football League. Working in a pro style offense also assists the transition from the college ranks to the pros. Many expect to hear Darius Walkers name come off the board in round two or three. Few expect him to contribute and contribute soon. Count me as one of the few.

 

 


 

 
Contact Webmaster
© 2007. War Room Report LLC. Legal Notice